A few weeks ago I was at a middle school during their after school program and two girls were interested enough to ask the nearest CM (Americorp Volunteer) who I was. He said that I worked with City Year, that I’m nice and that they could ask me questions themselves. They were, like 6th grade girls are, shy and giggly. The CM told me these girls wanted to ask me a few questions so I went over. After the first what do you do question, the next was a compliment. One of the girls told me I was pretty. I said thank you. She said that she was not pretty. I asked, “What do you think that means?” We then got into a discussion about boys and boyfriends. She told me that boys don’t like her. I said that’s because they are stupid when it comes to girls and that you may feel that way longer than you think should be normal. Then the girls said, “Ooo, you said a bad word.”
This 11 year old’s second response to me was about what she thought I looked like. She also thinks that somehow being pretty is linked to having a boyfriend. This compelled me to share with her that I, like her, don’t have a boyfriend and that somehow was reassuring. It made me a bit sad to think about how the feeling of not being liked hurt this 6th grader and I couldn’t say that it would get better, because it doesn’t. The more I’m in schools with kids, the more I am afraid we are not doing an adequate job of raising and building up good people who respect themselves and others. No kid should think that pretty means enough to tell a stranger, judge themselves on it or think pretty is how you measure how anyone likes you- particularly the subset of boys. What happened to liking who you are, being a good friend, having fun learning (because learning is fun, promise) and playing?
Another CM shared that one of her students, who is nice, has decided that next year when she gets to middle school she will have to be mean. According to her, it’s how it works in middle school, you can’t be nice because you will get picked on or be un-cool. Nice girls don’t have friends. This is a nightmare mindset for me. As someone who has been systematically betrayed or screwed over without provocation pretty much yearly, twice a year if I was lucky, from 5th grade through my junior year of college, I am not a fan of mean girls. Girls who are insecure and compete in a contest that only exists in their head and never tell you about it. Girls who thought that I should never have anything that they want and sometimes it would be things that they didn’t really want, just didn’t want me to have it. Another CM responded that at the middle school he works at the nice kids are the kids that no one really bothers. It’s the mean kids that are mean to each other regularly and the nice kids get picked on every once in a while, so nice is a good way. With a sigh, a pang in my heart and a bolt of anger I just said maybe she could ask her student which matters more, other people liking you or you liking you?
Do you like you? How do your actions reflect what matters to you?
May we be good to each other, simply because it is possible.


























